Red Sox Offseason: Trade Josh Beckett?

A Sports Blog by 98.5 The Sports Hub's Tucker Silva

BOSTON (CBS) – Throughout this crucial Red Sox offseason, I plan to provide my personal input regarding moves that could make sense for the 2012 team. This is purely my own speculation.

I can assure you that you won’t be seeing the following:

(Spoken in the “Sully Massarotti” voice, for you Felger and Mazz fans)

“Yea, I think the Sox should trade Lackey to the Dodger for Clayton Kershaw…the Dodgers would totally go for that in a hahtbeat. “

This blog will be a logical approach to what possibly could happen this offseason. Who knows? Maybe I might be in an interview for the void of Red Sox GM (kidding, calm down).

Move #1: Trade Josh Beckett

Rumors circulated towards the end of the season that Beckett added twenty-pounds during the 2011 season. In addition, a report surfaced that some Red Sox pitchers were drinking, eating chicken and playing video games during games on their off days.

Clearly, the evidence stacks up against Beckett.

Even though there are some personal characteristics that teams may question, Beckett does indeed have trade value. After all, he did have a productive 2011 season, posting a 2.89 ERA with 175 strikeouts and a low 1.03 WHIP. He’s more than qualified to serve as a solid number-two starter in any rotation.

That being said, a change of scenery may be best for both the Red Sox and Beckett.

Here’s my proposed deal:

The Boston Red Sox send P Josh Beckett to the Texas Rangers in exchange for 3B/DH Michael Young.

This deal could work simply because both players could benefit from a change of scenery. Young already voiced his strong displeasure during Spring Training, as he was forced serve as the Rangers DH for the majority of the 2011 season. He wants to play third-base and the Red Sox could fulfill that request for him.

Read: Tucker Silva’s Sports Blog

Plus, Young had an effective 2011 season, batting .338 with 11 HR’s and 106 RBI’s. The 34-year-old is a career .304 hitter and can be counted to play over 150 games per season.

Current Red Sox 3B Kevin Youkilis is a factor in this deal. The soon to be 33-year-old is clearly starting to break down like an old Volkswagen bus. Acquiring Young would leave the Red Sox with two options.

1.) Trade Youkilis
2.) Split Youkilis and Young’s time between third-base and DH

I would lean more towards the second option, as this would give the Sox a productive right-handed bat in addition to Youkilis. Of course, this would signal the end of David Ortiz’s era in Boston (currently a free agent).

The lineup could perhaps look something like this:

Reddick (or other)
Scutaro (or other)

In addition, both Beckett and Young’s contracts are quite similar. Young’s contract, which pays him $16-million per year, expires after the 2013 season. Beckett’s contract extends through the end of the 2014 season, paying him $15.75-million per year.

Read: Ellsbury Wins Comeback Player of the Year

The only issue in this deal is that the Red Sox would be sacrificing a quality arm in an already weak pitching rotation. However, the likes of Ortiz and JD Drew would be off the books, which could propel the Sox to chase top free agent pitcher CJ Wilson. Also, Yankees ace CC Sabathia is rumored to be leaning towards opting out of his current deal, thus making him a free agent.

This move would be a positive step towards improving the Red Sox poor clubhouse culture. It would also open the doors to signing a top free agent pitcher and it would quickly solve their heavy left-handed lineup.

Read: Dan Roche’s Sports Blog

Again, this is my own speculation. But you can bet I would explore this deal if I were in the GM’s driver seat.

You can follow 98.5 The Sports Hub’s Tucker Silva on twitter @TuckSilva.

  • brando-97

    The redsox also need to investigate Lester and Buckholz to ensure that these two buy into the new Redsox philosophy of team play and personal sacrifice during the season. These players are paid well to perform, not to drink beer and eat fried chicken and bisquits. What a waste of talent or in this case a waist of talent. I have said for 3 years that the Redsox look out of shape as the season progresses. There appears to be no real leader in the club house. Lester has the talent to challenge someone like Roy Holliday pitch for pitch, too bad he is wasting his talent being a primadonna and looking to place blame elsewhere other than in the mirror. This Redosx staff needs to be nixed and change to produce a great pitching staff. If Beckett was the problem than he has to go. Unfortunately you also have to get rid of at least one of the other players involved and since Lester has the most value to the team LAckey also has to go. Unless it is proven that indeed Lester was the ring leader in which case you keep Beckett and get rid of the other two. Lackey unfortunately, because of his poor performance and inviolvement is poster boy for trading and placing blame. We expected more from him because he has been such a force inthe league until he joined the Redsox. Obviously he has been kept on a tight leash by his past pitching coaches and managers. I think it is too bad that Beckett couldn’t have lead the pitching staff by positive example instead of being first in the beer and chicken line.

  • Report: Cherington Told By Red Sox He Is Next GM « CBS Boston

    […] Read: Should Red Sox Trade Josh Beckett? […]

  • Juan

    Actually Beckett to the Dodgers for Ethier would be better. Ethier has expressed interest in playing for the Red Sox. Former team-mate of Pedroia. Even if you have to throw in a prospect or two, i would do it.

    • Sam

      Make sure you take that “Over Paid” and poor excuse for a pitcher LACKEY with you when you leave BECKETT. You’ll need at least one drinking buddy before you can corrupt other plaers where you go, you JERK!

  • Randy Downes

    If we trade Beckett it better be for another pitcher. Signing CJ wilson to a FA deal would not be wise. He hasn’t been great in the postseason and is already 31 yrs old and likely looking for a 4-5 yr deal.

  • FireGuyFrank

    Trade him and every other beer swilling quitter on the team. The Paw Sox are more deserving of Red Sox Nation’s loyalty.

    See ya!

  • dan


  • Report: Cubs Make List, Business As Usual For Red Sox « CBS Boston

    […] Read: Should Red Sox Trade Josh Beckett? […]

  • Blast from the Past: A Look at the 2012 Red Sox Offseason « Sports On Tap (Beta)

    […] latest Kevin Youkilis trade, I thought it would be interesting to revisit an article I wrote for about the offseason approach the Red Sox should have taken at the end of the disastrous 2011 […]

blog comments powered by Disqus
Taz Show
Download Weather App

Listen Live