Theo Epstein’s Moves: Good and Bad

The%20Yankees%20reliever%20was%20one%20of%20Epstein%26%238217%3Bs%20first%20signings%20with%20the%20Red%20Sox%2C%20and%20did%20not%20work%20out%20as%20planned.%20After%20inking%20a%20two-year%2C%20%246.5%20million%20deal%2C%20Mendoza%20was%20part%20of%20the%20failed%20bullpen%20by%20committee%20experiment%2C%20and%20finished%20his%20two%20years%20in%20Boston%205-6%20with%20a%205.73%20ERA.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20Ezra%20Shaw%2FGetty%20Images%29

Mueller%20was%20brought%20in%20before%20the%202003%20season%2C%20and%20made%20a%20much%20bigger%20impact%20than%20expected.%20He%20ended%20up%20winning%20the%202003%20batting%20crown%2C%20and%20was%20a%20solid%20contributor%20to%20the%202004%20World%20Series%20team.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20Elsa%2FGetty%20Images%29

Epstein%20signed%20Mike%20Timlin%20off%20the%20scrap%20heap%20in%202003%2C%20and%20the%20righty%20reliever%20helped%20solidfy%20the%20Red%20Sox%20bullpen%20for%20the%20next%20six%20seasons.%20He%20played%20a%20pivitol%20role%20in%20the%202004%20World%20Championship%2C%20and%20finished%20his%20career%20in%20Boston%20with%20a%203.76%20ERA.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20Stephen%20Dunn%2FGetty%20Images%29

After%20the%20heartbreaking%20loss%20in%20the%202003%20playoffs%2C%20Epstein%20went%20out%20and%20landed%20the%20Red%20Sox%20another%20pitching%20ace%20in%20Curt%20Schilling.%20Schilling%20become%20a%20Red%20Sox%20legend%20for%20years%20to%20come%20after%20helping%20the%20Red%20Sox%20win%20two%20World%20Series%20titles%20in%20his%20four%20years%20in%20Boston.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20Al%20Bello%2FGetty%20Images%29

After%20it%20was%20apparent%20Boston%20needed%20a%20closer%2C%20Epstein%20courted%20Keith%20Foulke%20before%20the%202004%20season.%20The%20two%20attended%20a%20Celtics%20game%20together%2C%20and%20Foulke%20ended%20up%20signing%20a%20three-year%2C%20%2418.75%20million%20contract.%20He%20pitched%2014%20innings%20in%20the%202004%20postseason%2C%20and%20was%20on%20the%20mound%20when%20the%20Red%20Sox%20finally%20won%20the%20World%20Series.%20Although%20he%20was%20never%20the%20same%20after%20the%202004%20playoffs%2C%20Foulke%26%238217%3Bs%20performance%20was%20a%20big%20part%20in%20the%20Red%20Sox%20winning%20it%20all.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20Stephen%20Dunn%2FGetty%20Images%29%20

Late%20in%20the%202003%20free%20agency%20period%2C%20Epstein%20signed%20Twins%20DH%20David%20Ortiz.%20While%20the%20Red%20Sox%20were%20not%20expecting%20much%20out%20of%20Ortiz%2C%20he%20hit%2031%20homers%20and%20drove%20in%20101%20runs%20in%20just%20128%20games%20played.%20Ortiz%20went%20on%20to%20be%20one%20of%20Boston%26%238217%3Bs%20most%20clutch%20hitters%2C%20and%20has%20enjoyed%20a%20nine-year%20career%20as%20one%20of%20the%20faces%20of%20the%20franchise.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20Doug%20Pensinger%2FGetty%20Images%29

In%202004%2C%20Epstein%20sent%20Shea%20Hillenbrand%20to%20the%20Arizona%20Diamondbacks%20for%20closer%20Byung-Hyun%20Kim.%20While%20Kim%20did%20not%20work%20out%2C%20the%20move%20allowed%20Bill%20Mueller%20to%20take%20over%20at%20third%20base%20full-time%2C%20and%20David%20Ortiz%20to%20slide%20into%20the%20DH%20position.%20%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20credit%3A%20JOHN%20MOTTERN%2FAFP%2FGetty%20Images%29

At%20the%202004%20deadline%2C%20Theo%20sent%20prospect%20Henri%20Stanley%20to%20the%20Dodgers%20for%20utlility%20outfielder%20Dave%20Roberts.%20Roberts%20provided%20speed%20on%20the%20bases%2C%20and%20came%20up%20with%20one%20of%20the%20biggets%20plays%20of%20the%202004%20World%20Series%20run.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20Ezra%20Shaw%2FGetty%20Images%29

In%20his%20boldest%20moves%20as%20Red%20Sox%20GM%2C%20Epstein%20sent%20disgruntaled%20Red%20Sox%20star%20Nomar%20Garciaparra%20to%20the%20Cubs%2C%20along%20with%20Matt%20Murton%2C%20and%20received%20Orlando%20Cabrera%20from%20the%20Expos%20at%20the%202004%20trade%20deadline.%20Cabrera%26%238217%3Bs%20defense%20and%20attitude%20in%20the%20clubhouse%20helped%20spark%20Boston%26%238217%3Bs%20late%20season%20run%2C%20and%20helped%20propel%20them%20to%20their%20first%20World%20Series%20in%2086%20years.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20Al%20Bello%2FGetty%20Images%29

After%20Epstein%20decided%20not%20to%20re-sign%20Orlando%20Carbrera%2C%20he%20signed%20Renteria%20to%20a%20four-year%2C%20%2440%20million%20contract.%20In%20his%20only%20season%20in%20Boston%2C%20Renteria%20hit%20just%20.276%20and%20had%2030%20errors%2C%20and%20was%20traded%20to%20the%20Atlanta%20Braves%20for%20prospect%20Andy%20Marte%2C%20with%20the%20Red%20Sox%20eating%20a%20lot%20of%20the%20contract.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20Jim%20McIsaac%2FGetty%20Images%29

Clement%20was%20signed%20to%20a%20three-year%2C%20%2425%20million%20contract%20after%20the%20departure%20of%20Pedro%20Martinez.%20Clement%20made%20the%20All-Star%20team%20in%20his%20first%20season%20with%20Boston%2C%20going%2010-2%20before%20the%20break%2C%20but%20finished%20the%20season%20at%2013-6%20with%20a%204.57%20ERA.%20He%20was%20struck%20in%20the%20head%20by%20a%20line%20drive%20in%20July%2C%20and%20was%20never%20the%20same.%20He%20finished%20his%20two%20seasons%20in%20Boston%20with%20a%2018-11%20record%20and%205.09%20ERA.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20Jonathan%20Daniel%2FGetty%20Images%29

In%20March%20of%202006%2C%20Epstein%20sent%20pitcher%20Bronson%20Arroyo%20to%20the%20CIncinnatti%20Reds%20for%20slugger%20Wily%20Mo%20Pena.%20While%20Pena%20was%20expected%20to%20bring%20some%20more%20pop%20to%20the%20middle%20of%20the%20Boston%20lineup%2C%20he%20struggld%20mightily%20at%20the%20plate%2C%20he%20hit%20just%2011%20home%20runs%20in%2084%20games%20while%20batting%20.301.%20He%20was%20traded%20to%20the%20Washington%20Nationals%20after%20batting%20.218%20over%2073%20games%20in%202007.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20Jim%20McIsaac%2FGetty%20Images%29

Epstein%20long%20coveted%20Julio%20Lugo%2C%20and%20signed%20the%20short%20stop%20to%20a%20four-year%2C%20%2436-million%20contract%20before%20the%202007%20season.%20In%20his%20first%20season%20in%20Boston%2C%20Lugo%20hit%20just%20.237%20in%20147%20games.%20He%20had%2019%20errors%20in%202007%2C%20and%20followed%20that%20up%20with%2016%20in%2081%20games%20in%202008.%20Lugo%20was%20traded%20to%20the%20St.%20Louis%20Cardinals%20for%20Chris%20Duncan%20in%202009%20with%20Boston%20eating%20most%20of%20his%20remaining%20contract.%20Lugo%20finished%20his%20Red%20Sox%20career%20batting%20.251%20with%20103%20RBI%20in%20two%20and%20a%20half%20seasons.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20J.%20Meric%2FGetty%20Images%29

Theo%20and%20crew%20pulled%20out%20all%20the%20stops%20to%20sign%20Japanese%20pitching%20sensation%20Diasuke%20Matsuzaka.%20After%20posting%20a%20%2451%20million%20bid%20just%20to%20talk%20with%20Matsuzaka%2C%20the%20Red%20Sox%20signed%20him%20to%20a%20six-year%2C%20%2452%20million%20contract.%20%20After%20going%2033-15%20in%20his%20first%20two%20seasons%20with%20the%20Red%20Sox%20%28including%2018-3%2C%202.90%20ERA%20in%202008%29%2C%20Matsuzaka%20is%20just%2016-15%20the%20last%20three%20years%20while%20battling%20various%20injuries%20and%20control%20issues.%20Matsuzaka%20had%20to%20undergo%20Tommy%20John%20Surgery%20last%20season%2C%20and%20is%20not%20expected%20to%20return%20to%20the%20club%20until%20August%20at%20the%20earliest.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20Darren%20McCollester%2FGetty%20Images%29%20

To%20fill%20the%20void%20left%20by%20Johnny%20Damon%26%238217%3Bs%20depature%20to%20the%20Yankees%2C%20Epstein%20traded%20Guillermo%20Mota%2C%20Andy%20Marte%2C%20Kelly%20Shoppach%20and%20Cash%20to%20the%20Indians%20for%20Coco%20Crisp%2C%20Dave%20Riske%20and%20Josh%20Bard.%20While%20Crisp%20never%20filled%20Damon%26%238217%3Bs%20shoes%2C%20he%20spent%20three%20seasons%20in%20Boston%2C%20playing%20great%20defense%20in%20center%20field.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20Jim%20Rogash%2FGetty%20Images%29

Epstein%20signed%20Bobby%20Kielty%20in%20August%20of%202007%20to%20give%20the%20Red%20Sox%20outfield%20a%20bit%20more%20depth%20as%20they%20made%20their%20postseason%20run.%20Kielty%20did%20not%20do%20much%2C%20but%20in%20his%20only%20at%20bat%20during%20the%202007%20World%20Series%2C%20hit%20a%20solo%20home%20run%20late%20in%20Game%204%20on%20the%20only%20pitch%20he%20saw%2C%20which%20went%20on%20to%20be%20the%20game-winning%20run%20in%20the%204-3%20victory.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20Stephen%20Dunn%2FGetty%20Images%29

Drew%20signed%20a%20five-year%2C%20%2470-million%20contract%20before%20the%202007%20season.%20%20He%20will%20forever%20be%20remembered%20for%20his%20Game%206%20grand%20slam%20agains%20the%20Indians%20in%20the%202007%20ALCS%2C%20but%20never%20lived%20up%20to%20his%20big%20dollar%20contract.%20He%20played%20in%20606%20games%20over%20five%20seasons%20%28his%20140%20in%202007%20were%20the%20most%20in%20a%20season%20while%20with%20Boston%29%20and%20finished%20his%20Red%20Sox%20career%20with%20a%20.264%20batting%20average%20with%2080%20home%20runs%20and%20286%20RBI.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20J.%20Meric%2FGetty%20Images%29

After%20finally%20having%20enough%20Manny%20Ramirez%26%238217%3B%20antics%2C%20Epstein%20sent%20him%20to%20the%20LA%20Dodgers%20at%20the%202008%20trade%20deadline%20in%20a%20three-team%20deal%2C%20landing%20Jason%20Bay%20with%20the%20Red%20Sox.%20Bay%20hit%20.274%2C%20clubbing%2045%20home%20runs%20with%20the%20Sox%20in%20his%20season%20and%20a%20half%20in%20Boston%2C%20but%20was%20not%20re-signed%20when%20his%20deal%20expired.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20Elsa%2FGetty%20Images%29

Penny%20signed%20a%20one-year%2C%20%245%20million%20deal%20for%20the%202009%20season.%20After%20starting%205-1%20in%20his%20first%2010%20starts%2C%20Penny%202-7%20before%20being%20released%20in%20August.%20He%20ended%20his%20Red%20Sox%20career%20with%20a%207-8%20record%20and%20a%205.61%20ERA.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20Jim%20Rogash%2FGetty%20Images%29

Pineiro%20was%20signed%20to%20a%20one-year%2C%20%244%20million%20deal%20for%20the%202007%20season%20to%20help%20the%20Red%20Sox%20bullpen.%20In%2034%20innings%20pitched%2C%20Pineiro%20allowed%2020%20runs%20and%2041%20hits%20for%20a%205.03%20ERA.%20He%20was%20let%20go%20mid-season%2C%20and%20went%206-4%20for%20the%20Cardinals%20in%2011%20starts.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20Jim%20McIsaac%2FGetty%20Images%29

At%20the%202009%20trade%20deadline%2C%20Epstein%20traded%20Justin%20Masterson%2C%20Nick%20Hagadone%20and%20Bryan%20Price%20to%20the%20Cleveland%20Indians%20for%20catcher%2Ffirst%20baseman%20Victor%20Martinez.%20Martinez%20spent%20a%20season%20and%20a%20half%20with%20the%20Red%20Sox%2C%20batting%20.313%20with%2028%20homers%20and%20128%20RBI.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20Elsa%2FGetty%20Images%29%20

Epstein%20got%20lucky%20when%20third%20baseman%20Adrian%20Gonzalez%20agreed%20to%20a%20one-year%2C%20%2410%20million%20deal%20before%20the%202010%20season.%20Beltre%20was%20one%20of%20the%20more%20productive%20offensive%20players%20during%20the%20injury%20plagued%20season%20for%20Boston%2C%20batting%20.321%20with%2028%20homers%20and%20102%20RBI.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20Otto%20Greule%20Jr%2FGetty%20Images%29

Instead%20of%20signing%20Jason%20Bay%2C%20Epstein%20and%20the%20Red%20Sox%20gave%2037-year%20old%20Mike%20Cameron%20a%20two-year%2C%20%2415.5%20million%20deal.%20This%20moved%20Jacoby%20Ellsbury%20to%20left%20field%2C%20where%20he%20got%20hurt%2C%20and%20relied%20on%20Cameron%20to%20be%20the%20very%20day%20center%20fielder.%20He%20only%20played%20in%2048%20games%2C%20batting%20.259.%20He%20was%20released%20by%20the%20Sox%20during%20the%202011%20season.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20J.%20Meric%2FGetty%20Images%29

Epstein%20signed%20Crawford%20to%20a%20monster%20seven-year%2C%20%24142%20million%20dollar%20deal%20last%20winter.%20Crawford%20did%20not%20live%20up%20to%20the%20big%20dollars%20though%20in%20his%20first%20season%20in%20Boston%2C%20batting%20just%20.255%20with%2011%20homers%20and%2056%20RBI.%20He%20hit%20nearly%20everywhere%20in%20the%20Red%20Sox%20lineup%2C%20but%20saw%20most%20of%20his%20time%20at%20their%20number-eight%20hitter.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20Elsa%2FGetty%20Images%29

Epstein%20sent%20four%20prospects%20to%20San%20Diego%20to%20get%20Gonzalez%2C%20who%20signed%20a%20seven-year%2C%20%24154%20million%20contract%20extension%20with%20his%20new%20team.%20Gonzalez%20thrived%20in%20Fenway%20Park%2C%20setting%20career%20highs%20in%20batting%20average%20%28.338%29%2C%20hits%20%28213%29%20and%20runs%20scored%20%28108%29%20in%20his%20first%20year%20in%20Boston.%20He%20stuggled%20at%20the%20end%20of%20the%20season%2C%20but%20finished%20with%2027%20home%20runs%20and%20117%20RBI.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20Elsa%2FGetty%20Images%29

Epstein%20found%20a%20gem%20off%20the%20scrap%20heep%2C%20signing%20Alfredo%20Aceves%20to%20a%20one-year%2C%20%24650%2C000%20deal.%20Aceves%20was%20one%20of%20the%20more%20steady%20arms%20on%20the%20Boston%20pitching%20staff%2C%20alllowing%20just%2037%20runs%20in%20114%20innings%20pitched.%20He%20finished%20the%20year%2010-2%20with%20a%202.61%20ERA%2C%20mostly%20seeing%20time%20out%20of%20the%20bullpen.%20Aceves%20also%20made%20four%20starts%20during%20the%20season%2C%20and%20by%20the%20end%20of%20the%20year%20had%20teammates%20pushing%20for%20his%20spot%20in%20the%20starting%20five.%3Cbr%20%2F%3E%28Photo%20by%20Ed%20Zurga%2FGetty%20Images%29