NEWwbztv-small wbz-am-small 985-small mytv38web2

Curious About A Possible New Tax?

By Ken Tucci, WBZ-TV

View Comments
(credit: AP)

(credit: AP)

From Declare Your Curiosity

There is a potential bill HR-4646 concerning a 1% tax on all bank transactions.  This would be a very costly burden on all Americans.  Why have I not seen anything about this on the news?  - Patricia, Gloucester

Probably because this bill has virtually no chance of passing, and because the issue has been misrepresented by an email that’s been making the rounds for the last year or so.

That email says:  “President Obama’s finance team and Nancy Pelosi are recommending a 1% transaction tax on all financial transactions.  The bill is HR-4646 introduced by US Rep Peter deFazio D-Oregon and US Senator Tom Harkin D-Iowa.”

Not true.  President Obama’s finance team and Rep. Pelosi aren’t recommending this, and Rep. DeFazio and Sen. Harkin have nothing to do with it.  It’s the work of one congressman.

What’s true is that there is an HR-4646 that has been introduced a number of times since 2004 by Pennsylvania Rep. Chaka Fattah.  It would create a 1% transaction tax as well as phase out the federal income tax.  It’s referred to as The Debt Free America Act.  The tax would be used primarily to pay down the debt.  No other legislator has signed on as a co-sponsor and it’s never gotten out of committee.

So while the bill is real, the email is wrong.  For more details on both those topics go here.

This is another one of those pain in the neck emails we all seem to get, at least in my opinion.  I don’t trust anyone who distorts the facts on either side of the political aisle.

Do you get these emails and what do they say?

View Comments
  • Dean Smith

    Gee, I guess if they can require all seniors to get a bank account for auto deposit then I guess the Dems have just removed any excuse that they use to not require official I.D. to vote. They claim that requiring I.D. to vote would disenfranchise older minority voters because they have no official I.D. If this is true oh how oh how will they be able to open a bank account? I guess they just won’t be able to get their benefits.

  • http://fellowshipofminds.wordpress.com/2010/09/14/new-1-transaction-tax/ Obama’s New 1% Transaction Tax | Fellowship of the Minds

    [...] reports, Aug. 24, 2011, that HR 4646 has no co-sponsor and has virtually no chance of passing, and that [...]

  • Betty

    As of today “Snopes” is still claiming that HR 4646 is being sponser by deFazio & Harkin and that it is a bill that will levy a 1% tax/fee on all banking transactions. Most people are not going to their research to determine the truth. I can’t even get information on the House Of Representatives web site concerning this particular bill. Do you know how I can get the correct information about this bill?
    Thank you,
    Betty

  • http://www.prisonofficer.org/politics/14953-debt-free-america-act-aka-1-transaction-bill.html#post149469 The Debt Free America Act (aka the 1% Transaction Bill)

    [...] [...]

  • T

    look up h.r.1125 from Rep. Fattah

  • Doris

    Always contact your Representative or Senator directly and ask for clarification. I always get a reply.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Listen Live!

Follow CBS Boston

Like us on foursquare

Select a Live Stream