Local

Nantucket Murder Conviction Reversed Due To Jury Flaws

By Mark Pratt, Associated Press
View Comments
Thomas Toolan III (2004 AP file photo)

Thomas Toolan III (2004 AP file photo)

BOSTON (AP) — The highest court in Massachusetts has reversed the murder conviction of a former New York banking executive who was accused of fatally stabbing his former girlfriend on the exclusive island of Nantucket in 2004.

The Supreme Judicial Court said in its decision released on Tuesday that there were flaws in the way the jury for the trial of Thomas Toolan III was selected, especially since Nantucket is such an insular community.

elizabeth lochtefeld Nantucket Murder Conviction Reversed Due To Jury Flaws

Elizabeth Lochtefeld (2003 AP file photo)

Toolan, a former Citigroup executive, was convicted of killing Elizabeth Lochtefeld in 2007.

The court ruled that many of the people in the jury pool had either direct ties to the victim’s family, or close ties to potential witnesses in the case.

The slaying was the first on Nantucket in more than two decades.

The SJC has ordered a new trial.

(Copyright 2011 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.)

View Comments
blog comments powered by Disqus
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 2,701 other followers