By Jon Keller

BOSTON (CBS) – When the Red Sox fired John Farrell, I didn’t approve, but I understood. Even though he won a World Series and won the division twice in a row, overcoming player injuries and beating cancer in the process, Farrell made his share of mistakes and the team was perceived as underperforming.

But Joe Girardi, canned as manager of the Yankees?

Are you kidding me?

During his decade in arguably the toughest managerial job in baseball, Girardi won a title and made it to the postseason six times, winning the division three times. This year he superbly handled a young team, mixed in new players halfway through, and took the Yankees to within a game of the World Series.

Plus, he’s always struck me as a class act, and that’s high praise from someone who hates the Yankees and everything they stand for.

I get it, this is how it works in sports, and maybe there was stuff going on with both Farrell and Girardi that we didn’t know about.

But I wonder if these firings are part of a long running cultural trend toward excessive impatience and perverse fascination with the greener grass on the other side of the fence?

Think about presidential politics, where four of the last six presidents have been relatively untested newcomers elected by voters mostly just wanting something new, regardless of how worthwhile that something might be.

Think of high-tech consumer products, the endless hunger for the newest app, video game, or smartphone.

Think of the divorce rate.

Is this obsession with change and the new validated by outcomes?

Ask me next fall when we see if Farrell and Girardi’s replacements did any better.

  1. “…someone who hates the Yankees and everything they stand for….”

    And you rail about divisiveness and denegration all the time?

    Sorry, Jon, you need to stop being such a hypocrite.

    When you opine about hating another city’s sports team, what message does that sent to youngsters listening to your broadcasts?

    And no, don’t tell me to lighten up. Its the part about the entertainment sector, and yes you are still basically entertainment in spite of your claim to be “a journalist”, that is insidious as it worms its way further into the subconsciousness of impressionable minds.

    Perhaps you should reassess some of your assumptions about the world that you help to create.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s