MILFORD (CBS) – Police are searching for two missing goats that escaped, were caught, and then were stolen by two men pretending to own the animals.

The domesticated goats initially escaped from their Chestnut Street home on Tuesday, but were corralled by neighbors.

READ MORE: 'I Thought It Was A Scam': Darrell Washington Of Weymouth, Daniela Maldonado Of Chelsea Named First VaxMillions Winners

While the neighbors were waiting for the Animal Control Officer, two Spanish speaking men pulled up and claimed the goats were theirs.

READ MORE: 'It Was Just Horrific': 2 Hospitalized After Early Morning Car Crash In Easton

The men took the goats and left.

Police said the goats, named Mamacita and Tree Star, belong to a woman who has raised them since they were born.

MORE NEWS: Former Cardinal Theodore McCarrick Charged With Indecent Assault In Wellesley

Milford Police said the goat’s owner is asking whoever took the animals to return them, no questions asked.