Baseball playoff ratings are up as NFL's overall downturn continues

By Matt Dolloff, CBS Boston

BOSTON (CBS) — Last season’s Week 6 Sunday Night Football showdown between the Patriots and Colts drew a 14.6 overnight rating, which at the time was the best total since 1997 for an NFL primetime game going against baseball’s league championship series. Sunday night between the Colts and Houston Texans, however, had a drastically different result.

According to SI’s Richard Deitsch, the Sunday Night Football contest between Indianapolis and Houston drew a 9.0 overnight rating, a 38.4 percent drop from Patriots-Colts in the same time slot last season and the worst total for the program since Colts-Saints in 2011. The Texans won 26-23.

FOX’s late-afternoon slate of games, however, saw a boost in ratings year-over-year. The network’s double-header of Cowboys-Packers and Eagles-Redskins averaged a 13.6 rating, which is up from an 11.3 drawn by Seahawks-Panthers in Week 6 last season, according to FOX Sports exec Michael Mulvihill. Ratings for CBS’s slate of games have yet to be released.

The uptick in FOX’s ratings may lead analysts to point to the quality of the games themselves as the reason for the decline in the NFL’s ratings in 2016. Cowboys-Packers was a marquee matchup between two of the NFL’s biggest fan bases and markets. However, it’s hard to believe that Colts-Texans was so much worse of a product than Patriots-Colts last year for the ratings to drop by nearly 40 percent, despite the massive intrigue surrounding the Patriots’ rematch with the Colts from the 2014 AFC Championship Game. Was Colts-Texans really the least watchable SNF game in five years? (Well, it might have been.)

Fans hold up a "USA" sign during the national anthem before the game between the San Francisco 49ers and Buffalo Bills on October 16, 2016 in Buffalo, New York. (Photo by Brett Carlsen/Getty Images)

Fans hold up a “USA” sign during the national anthem before the game between the San Francisco 49ers and Buffalo Bills on October 16, 2016 in Buffalo, New York. (Photo by Brett Carlsen/Getty Images)

The elephant in the room continues to be the growing movement of fans who are boycotting the NFL over the rampant national anthem protests by NFL players, which was sparked by 49ers quarterback Colin Kaepernick. San Francisco played in Buffalo on Sunday, where Bills fans booed Kaepernick and chanted “U.S.A.!” before he kneeled during the national anthem. Colts tight end Dwayne Allen kneeled after the national anthem Sunday night, but later clarified that it was a simple prayer and not a protest.

There is data to support the idea that a large segment of Americans are viewing the national anthem protests as a tipping point for them as NFL viewers, responding by changing the channel. FOX’s ratings growth on Sunday’s late-afternoon slate showed that high-quality matchups can still draw in viewers, but the precipitous drop for primetime matchups on Sunday and Monday night so far in 2016 can still be attributed to a confluence of factors.

Deitsch also reported that Game 2 of the NLCS between the Chicago Cubs and Los Angeles Dodgers drew a 5.0 rating, which makes it the most-watched event in the young history of the FOX Sports 1 network. Game 4 of the 2016 NLDS between the Cubs and Giants was previously FS1’s highest-rated contest. While baseball’s ratings still pale in comparison to the NFL overall, the boost in its own ratings (as well as the NHL) is worth watching as it coincides with the NFL’s downturn.

It’s clear that FOX benefitted from featuring two strong matchups, as those have been hard to find so far in 2016. But as evidenced by the plummeting SNF and Monday Night Football ratings, the overall problem is clearly still there for the NFL. As long as fans continue to grow tired of not just the quality of the game broadcasts and product on the field, but what many of them view as a sign of disrespect toward the American flag and national anthem, there’s little reason to believe the overall numbers will improve anytime soon.

Matt Dolloff is a writer for Any opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect that of CBS or 98.5 The Sports Hub. Have a news tip or comment for Matt? Follow him on Twitter @mattdolloff and email him at

Comments (14)
  1. slickone says:

    Great news! Love hering nbc lose in the rating!! nbc sucks the big one! I hope the nfl takes it on the chin also!

  2. Donald J Trump says:

    People actually have to get up early for work now, under Bush everybody could stay in!

  3. jimjam says:

    think its funny how they will do just about anything to keep from admitting the boycott is hurting them

  4. Carolyn LeBrun says:

    Spoiled, immature ‘children’ vying for attention, I.E. Colin Kaepernick and those following his lead, are playing a substantial role in the ratings decline. Yet, the news media and NFL corporate employers choose to ignore a considerable percentage of their fan base.
    It all brings to mind the legendary phrase “Nero fiddled while Rome burned”, followed by the quote, “Those who fail to learn from history are doomed to repeat it.”
    Hey, NFL …… Rome is burning!

  5. John says:

    I am not watching due to the Anthem protests. Haven’t watched a single NFL hike all year.

  6. boromir says:

    Good. Stopped watching due to the anthem protest and I haven’t missed it much at all. Not one second of one game and not one second of advertising. I hope the networks and the advertisers rake the league over the coals over this. It is the only way they will learn.

  7. F Football says:

    Good. I’d like to see everyone stop watching football and stop attending NFL games. These people are just a little too full of themselves if you ask me. I mean really now.. a league that pays it’s commissioner 40 million dollars a year ! Are you kidding me ! And Mr. Kraft.. supposedly a man of the fans. Yea sure.. He’s got now problem setting ticket prices so high you have to take a second mortgage on your home to go to a game. F Football !

  8. Martin says:

    Havent watched it all year and at this point I wont be back. Found better things to do with that time.

  9. I’ve watched my home team a couple of times but that’s it. No MNF or TNF or SNF when the players take a knee, I turned it off!

  10. John Smith says:

    Have not watched and will not watch again.Lots of spoiled brats and the NFL lets them get away with it.BBQed the tickets I had for 3 games this year.Grandson no happy but we can go fishing.

  11. Jacob R says:

    As a sports fan, Baseball is a much more cerebral game and definitely more exciting in the postseason than the NFL. Used to watch a lot of NFL, not so much anymore, and frankly, I don’t miss it.

  12. BRENDA SHEPARD says:

    Hopefully, the NFL will come to the conclusion of why the rating are plummeting . They are in total denial unwilling to face the truth about the problem causing this weekly recurrence of poor ratings. First of all, it does not have anything to do with the Presidential election, or Peyton Manning and Tom Brady’s absence or fans watching football on iPhone or
    I-pad or fantasy football either and all your other lousy excuses. Your American NFL fans are no longer watching NFL games due to your thuggish criminal football players not enthusiastically supporting the United States and its ways of life which includes Honoring the U.S. Flag and the National Anthem. Good Riddance!!!

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s