Watch CBS News

3 Dead Are Related To Vermont Shooting Suspect, Officials Say

BERLIN, Vt. (CBS/AP) — Three women found dead in a Vermont home on Saturday were related to a woman arrested a day earlier in the fatal shooting of a state social worker, state police said.

Three bodies were found on Saturday morning around 8 at an Airport Road home in Berlin, and police said at least two appeared to have been shot. The women were related to Jody Herring, who police said fatally shot a state social worker in neighboring Barre late Friday afternoon, police said.

"It is our belief that Julie Falzarano, who was aunt of the accused murderer, and her cousins Regina (Herring) and Rhonda (Herring) also had their lives taken from them," said Gov. Peter Shumlin during a press conference late Saturday night.

Authorities said the social worker, Lara Sobel, had handled a case for the state Department for Children and Families in which Herring's daughter was removed from the home.

Witnesses told police Herring shot Sobel twice before she was apprehended by several bystanders.

Herring, 40, of Barre Town, Vermont, was arrested Friday and charged with first-degree murder.

She is being held without bail until her arraignment on Monday Washington County Court.

Jody Herring
Jody Herring. (Photo Credit: Barre City Police Department)

Shumlin, who was returning from a Nova Scotia vacation a week early after receiving word of the deaths, said Saturday there was no reason to believe there was a continuing threat related to the incidents.

"The Vermont State Police are working collaboratively with the Barre and Berlin police and the investigation remains ongoing," Shumlin said in a statement. "Vermonters should know that there is no indication of a broader threat at this time to state employees or the general public.

"The tragedy that has gripped our state over the past 20 hours is immense. In the coming days we will need to pull together as a state to come to terms with these heinous events," Shumlin said.

Authorities said Friday night that Sobel had been involved in a case that saw Herring's 9-year-old daughter taken into state custody. Sobel had just left a DCF office on Friday afternoon when she was shot twice, authorities said. The child remains in state custody, officials said.

Lt. Gov. Phil Scott said he knew several members of the extended Herring family.

"It's my understanding after speaking with some of her (Jody Herring's) relatives that her father was one of 16 brothers and sisters. It's a large, extended family throughout central Vermont," Scott said.

Ken Schatz, the commissioner for the Department for Children and Families, called Sobel's shooting "a heartbreaking tragedy." He called Sobel "an experienced social worker. She had been providing public service for children and families for more than 14 years."

Vermont's child protection agency, like those in many other states, frequently comes under criticism from parents for being too quick to remove children from homes in cases of alleged abuse and neglect; and from the public when children are left in the home and end up dying at the hands of family members.

A special legislative committee was set up to investigate the department system after the deaths last year of two toddlers who had been involved with DCF, 2-year-old Dezirae Sheldon, of Poultney, and 15-month-old Peighton Geraw, of Winooski. Murder charges are pending against Dezirae's stepfather and Peighton's mother, who have pleaded not guilty.

Following the investigation, Vermont passed a new law designed to improve communications between the department, law enforcement and the courts.

The shootings remain under investigation by police.

Back at the farmhouse where the bodies were found, a family member was trying to comprehend the horror of what has taken place.

"That hit me right in the neck and in the throat," says David Huntley. "It's going to be really tough to take."

(TM and © Copyright 2015 CBS Radio Inc. and its relevant subsidiaries. CBS RADIO and EYE Logo TM and Copyright 2015 CBS Broadcasting Inc. Used under license. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.)

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.