By Karen Anderson, WBZ-TV

MILFORD (CBS) – A brother of the man charged with running down 23-year-old Matthew Denice in Milford is now charged with stabbing a man this weekend.

WBZ NewsRadio 1030’s Lana Jones reports.

David Segundo Dutan Guaman is charged with armed assault after a stabbing at his home on Water Street in Milford early Saturday morning. He is an illegal immigrant, and was wanted on warrants in connection with driving violations.

His brother, Nicolas Guaman, is charged with driving a pick up truck that struck and killed Matthew Denice last August.

Another brother, Pablo Guaman, is charged with giving Nicolas the truck. He is out on bail, wearing a monitoring bracelet.

WBZ-TV’s Karen Anderson reports

ICE officials say at this point it appears David was not in their system. State officials confirm they did not have any fingerprints from him prior to the weekend stabbing. Now, ICE has launched a retainer against David Guaman, which means if he is let out of custody, ICE has 48 hours to take him into custody.

Milford’s Police Chief Thomas O’Loughlin says this case is a reminder to the community of Matthew Denice’s death, and the frustrations with the lack of comprehensive immigration reform. He says if the program, Secure Communities, was in place in Massachusetts, David would not have been identified because he hadn’t been arrested in a violent crime; however, he says other measures are needed to strengthen immigration laws. He says, “When is the federal government going to do something about individuals such as David Guaman and his brother? Until they do something, local police and state police we are in the middle dealing with the issues.”

Wendy Murphy, who represents Matt’s family, says, “Mathew Denice’s family is very distraught to hear there is, in a sense, the same kind of problem in this case.” Both men are illegal immigrants and both have driving records. Murphy says, “It looks like there is a systemic problem, in the sense that people who are here illegally, and are being coddled by the legal system, are escalating their illegal behavior, and we’re seeing acts of violence.”

Murphy says while Secure Communities would not have lead to David’s deportation before the stabbing, it is a tool that could help collected data and monitor crimes. She says Governor Patrick should reverse course and ask for it to be implemented to help understand the facts. “The public has a right to be angry, and has a right to ask political leaders of the state, why aren’t you measuring the problem?”

Governor Deval Patrick has opposed the Secure Communities program. Last year, ICE announced it will be implemented in every state by the end of 2013.

11.2 million people live in the United States illegally. Officials with ICE say they can only deport 400,000 people per year because of their financial resources. For that reason, they say they focus on deporting violent criminals.

David Guaman will be arraigned on Tuesday in Milford District Court.

The victim in the stabbing is expected to survive.

The Denice family released the following statement:

“Despite all the promises that were made by local officials, politicians, and leaders in the Ecuadorian community after our son Matthew Denice was killed, David Guaman, like his brother Nicolas, who killed Matthew, should not have been free to become involved in more serious violence. We are extremely concerned that despite all the promises that were made, about how things would soon improve and that the public would be better protected, nothing much has changed. Unlicensed drivers are cited on a daily basis, many of them after being involved in accidents or for being pulled over for driving drunk. Without proper training, passing a written test and a road test these drivers put all of our lives at risk on a daily basis. In Milford there has been a huge increase in excessive drinking that has resulted in several violent assaults over the last few months like this most recent stabbing by David Dutan-Guaman.

Our son Matthew Denice paid the ultimate price with his life because Nicolas Dutan-Guaman, who was in the country illegally, had a criminal record, and was unlicensed, chose to get drunk and drive. We are still deeply disappointed that when Govenor Patrick had the opportunity he did not chose to participate in the Secure Communities Program that would eventually lead to deportation of the most serious offenders illegally in our country.”

Comments (14)
  1. Jenny says:

    Can we friggin deport all these illegal wastes of life please. back to their country and let them deal with it in their jails on their dime??? Man, metro west has just become a latin illegal haven. what a shame.

  2. fred says:

    Why does the familly of Matthew Denice have to be put through this? Thanks governor Patrick – this stabbing is on you as well all other other crimes committed by persons (illegals) who have been arrested and let go.

  3. DoverDavid says:

    Get these people the heck out of here! Their here illegally and commit crimes which should have never have happened in the first place. No release, transport him out of here and put his info on a list so that he will never return!

  4. mmarcia says:

    Ok, what do they not get about being here ILLEGALLY? They should have been rounded up and deported when they were discovered.

    Do you know what happens if you’re in Mexico illegally? They deport you. And most of the countries around the world – they deport you. Man up, Americans, and urge your US Senators and US Representatives to enact a Deportation Law!!

  5. Foolishness says:

    Welcome to Massachusetts, welcoming safe haven for illegals who come here ILLEGALLY and leech off the state, commit crimes, use stolen identities……. this stupid liberal state welcomes and shelters them, does nothing when they get state assistance that us hard-working tax-paying fools have to pay for…… but hey, keep electing the Liberals you fools! This is what you get

  6. YaKnow says:

    Well, according to our Fearless Leader, Duhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhval, this Illegal’s POS brother killed that young man, And please correct me if I am wrong. Duhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhval said, being ILLEGAL has nothing to do with it…..UN F’ing BELIEVABLE…

    1. Willow says:

      These people are breaking the law if they are in the country illegally, whether they commit and act of violence or not.

  7. emom says:

    HEY how in the H#LL did they get in this country in the first place.. Train, Plane, Bus, Car, Boat, did they just walk into the country or state,,,, Did this piece of work have a job,,,,,, who hired him,,,,, look into that piece of work ,, see how many are here illegally,,,,,,,Wheres there ONE there’s a hundred.. living in some huge apartment building,,, seems like they get here and live in boarding houses,,,,,,,, where did he level,,, check for citizenships on others living there,, sure there are many to be found.Sick of stupid DUUUUUHHHHHH VAAAAALLLLLL,,, he is a waste of time and a piece of work,, what a TOOL<,,,, they all look the other way and just ignore,,,,,,,,

  8. billbranch says:

    As much as our enlightened liberal brethren might tell us that diversity is so wonderful, let these slimy scumbags get in here legally. I can only imagine being a police officer in Massachusetts and trying to get this crap off the roads and deported.
    We have our chance in November. Vote early, vote often. vote Republican and let’s get our country back.

  9. forumsforjustice says:

    Illegal Immigration

  10. AngelicaS says:

    These ILLEGAL FOREIGN NATIONALS have been identified, and our government has known who they are— for this reason— IT IS INEXCUSABLE that they they have not been DEPORTED ALREADY! Why is our government permitting these ILLEGAL ALIENS to terrorize American citizens and LEGAL immigrants! This is absolutely disgusting!