The hypothetical debate of “Would you trade Tom Brady for Andrew Luck?” generated such great discussion a few weeks ago, Toucher & Rich decided to have Hypothetical Tuesday every week.
Questions up for debate:
1. If Colin Kaepernick loses every game for the rest of the season will the San Francisco 49ers keep Alex Smith on the roster?
2. If Tim Tebow starts this weekend and wins out the rest of the season does Jets GM Mike Tannenbaum keep his job?
3. If you were the Red Sox would you sign Josh Hamilton for four years, max money if you knew that he would post consistently good numbers yet miss 40 percent of his games?